The Media Drop

Taking a page out of the slacker handbook this week is apparently The Australian’s Frank Devine, who finds that sources are much more easy to get quotes from when you just Google the topic you are looking for, make a few key changes to the exact quotations and information that someone else acquired, and print them in your own article. Some people say that journalists are getting information and topics to write about from blogs, and I don’t doubt it, since it works most of the time in the other direction - but I think this is just a bit silly. What follows below comes to me via a colleague of mine, who figured it was right up my alley and thought it wise that more people are made aware of it.

Way back on January 19, Arabisto.com contributor Rima Abdelkader published this item entitled “FOX TV Show ‘24′ Angers Arab/Muslim Fans in the United States and Abroad,” featuring comments from New York-based law student and Arab-American Sawsan Zaky, who expressed horror towards FOX’s hit show because of how it showed Muslims in America - and that’s just part of the quality story that Abdelkader had put together. Here’s where Devine fits in. Seems that he thought the same about the work from the Arabisto site, and used slightly altered quotes in this commentary, published on Feburary 2 under the hed of “There’s no villainy in reflecting the truth about terrorists.” It seems that Sawsan Zaky is either the most quoted person from the Arab-American community when it comes to 24, or his quote is just really really good and it’s no big deal if we tweak a few words here and there. Devine also did a really good job of sourcing information about Dr. Jack Shaheen, who told Abdelkader about his research on film and television and its portrayal of Muslims - but never spoke with the Australian staffer.

As it turns out, Crikey’s Jane Nethercote was able to get in touch with Devine, something that the folks at Arabisto unfortunately weren’t able to do when they wrote about how this all went down, in an item by Nadia Gergis on Feburary 2. Devine apparently told Crikey that he found Abdelkader’s item in Google, and used it “as a reference” because it was “among the more up to date.” How quaint.

In my eyes, this is just as lazy as people who use Wikipedia as a flat out source, rather than a strong starting point that has excellent links to original, [we hope] reputable sources of information. I mean, if you read it on the Internet, it must be true, right? Frank Devine may be penning under the world of being a columnist, but after being editor at the Chicago Sun-Times and executive editor of the New York Post two decades ago, you’d think he would know better. It’s not so hard to say “In fact, one outspoken blogger found out firsthand from Arab-Americans in the New York City area that…” in your column, now is it?

Another tsk, tsk is the least of Frank Devine’s worries at this point, and I seriously hope that I’ve done my part to spread this story on this side of the globe.