2) $newskin=2; } elseif (isset($skin)) { $newskin=(int)$skin; if ($skin<1) $newskin=2; if ($skin>2) $newskin=2; } else { $newskin=2; } $skin=$newskin; $headervar = "/home/mediamogul/www/www.themediadrop.com/docs/skins/header"; $footervar = "/home/mediamogul/www/www.themediadrop.com/docs/skins/footer"; $extension = ".php"; ?> The Media Drop: Getting sandbagged isn't fun.

Advertisements on TMD are not
endorsements of any company,
product or service.
Advertising Policy
Email: themediadrop@gmail.com
AIM/Yahoo!: themediadrop
MSN Messenger: tom@themediadrop.com
ICQ: 512240
First Post
Colophon
Comment Policy
TMD Forums
The Media Drop


« March 2007
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
    1 2 3 4 5
6 7 8 9 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30 31    



Google

Total Entries: 2556
Total Comments: 1170
Search Statistics
March 2007
February 2007
January 2007
December 2006
November 2006
October 2006
September 2006
August 2006
July 2006
June 2006
May 2006
April 2006
March 2006
February 2006
January 2006
December 2005
November 2005
October 2005
September 2005
August 2005
July 2005
June 2005
May 2005
April 2005
March 2005
February 2005
January 2005
December 2004
November 2004
October 2004
September 2004
August 2004
July 2004
June 2004
May 2004
April 2004
March 2004
February 2004
January 2004
WordPress
Magazines aren't quite dead yet
NBC holds off hatred by at least 7 minutes
My advertising offer to the electronics retailer industry
Jennifer Love Hewitt has her Hanes on again
Is NBC ditching Brian Williams' producer?
Fun with Viacom and YouTube
CNN journalist robbed in South Africa
An old funny
Reclaiming my blog on Technorati
Advertising & Marketing - 136 post(s)
BloggerCon IV - 5 post(s)
Blogging - 253 post(s)
BlogNashville - 7 post(s)
Books - 15 post(s)
Breaking News - 50 post(s)
Columnists - 4 post(s)
Comics - 1 post(s)
Commentary - 24 post(s)
Content Changes - 2 post(s)
Coverage Issues - 24 post(s)
DVD Reviews - 1 post(s)
Editorialism - 5 post(s)
Election 2004 - 105 post(s)
Ethics - 86 post(s)
Fun With Media - 88 post(s)
FYIs - 23 post(s)
IM Excerpts - 2 post(s)
Interviews - 14 post(s)
Introduction - 3 post(s)
Job Stuff - 4 post(s)
Journalism - 219 post(s)
Journalism Concerns - 89 post(s)
Katrina - 11 post(s)
Life - 13 post(s)
Magazines - 65 post(s)
Mergers & Acquisitions - 41 post(s)
Mobile Media - 4 post(s)
Movie Reviews - 3 post(s)
Movies - 16 post(s)
Music - 93 post(s)
Networking - 17 post(s)
Newspapers - 331 post(s)
Personalities - 95 post(s)
Pictures - 1 post(s)
Podcasting - 3 post(s)
Politics - 6 post(s)
Public Relations - 2 post(s)
Quote of the Day - 15 post(s)
Radio - 246 post(s)
Randomosities - 3 post(s)
Regulatatory Issues - 33 post(s)
Resignations - 1 post(s)
RSS - 4 post(s)
Site Changes - 28 post(s)
Sports Marketing - 4 post(s)
Sports on Television - 61 post(s)
Stylebook - 1 post(s)
Super Bowl XLI - 13 post(s)
Surveys - 4 post(s)
Television - 337 post(s)
The Internet - 174 post(s)
The Media Economy - 175 post(s)
War In Iraq - 31 post(s)
Bloglines
Deepblog
Google News
Kinja | The Media Drop Digest
PubSub
Technorati
Topix
xmatrix
Abused by the News
Bacon's MediaSource
The Book Standard
Broadcasting & Cable
BusinessWire
DIYMedia.net
Editor & Publisher
Folio:
Hollywood Reporter
iwantmedia.com
mediabistro
MediaChannel.org
MediaGuardian
MediaPost
Media Life Mag
MediaWeek
Newspaper Association of America
Power Lunch
Poynteronline
Press Release Newswire 24-7 PRNewswire.com
PRWeek
Publishers Weekly
RatherBiased.com
TelevisionWeek
The Advertising Show
The Daily Planet
The NewsMarket
TV Barn
TVPredictions
TVSpy
Variety
WaPo's Media Notes
Yahoo! Marketing & Advertising Directory
Yahoo! Media Directory
LinkedIn
Upcoming.org


RSS Feed:



Powered by
Movable Type 3.31

Listed on BlogShares


Skinning and Red/Black Design by
Moxie Design Studios


August 24, 2004
Getting sandbagged isn't fun.

This morning, Michelle Malkin recalled the events that transpired Thursday evening on MSNBC's "Hardball" with Chris Matthews. Specifically, she's pointing out how she was brought on to speak on certain topics, including national security, the FBI, and her book - but was told shortly before going on air that this would be changed to the Swift Boat Veterans and then her book. That's all fine, and happens all the time. But this was followed up with a switch of Dana Milbank off the panel - who was confirmed just hours earlier - and then replaced with Willie Brown. Malkin confirms via email that the replacement of Milbank was "At the last minute--literally." Yet again, perhaps something came up with Milbank, though he appeared in the next segment - but this isn't the first example of a guest being asked to come on a show to debate or discuss something in particular, only to have the topic be completely different by the time the show is taped. I'm not going to sit here and say that every talk show host or producer is "out to get" the guests that are booked, but I absolutely disagree that people aren't put into "ambush" situations on purpose on occasion.

Most journalists and some subject matter experts are slick enough to switch topics on a whim, but that doesn't mean this should become the rule, rather than the exception. Was there a super drastic change in the Swift Boat Veterans story that forced the issue to become the official topic of discussion on the show, and have Dana Milbank moved off the panel? I'm not sure that there was, to be honest.

Finally, I think if Matthews is going to hammer Malkin about the "self-inflicted" injury that John Kerry received a Purple Heart for, he's no better than anyone on any other show or if he's not going to let her answer the question in total. And clarify what they're saying. And that includes the panel on any episode of Jerry Springer's show all the way over to Sean Hannity. Something being "self-inflicted" doesn't necessarily mean that they "shot themself" or whatever. She was absolutely stating that in the book people alleged that Kerry's wounds were "self-inflicted." Perhaps if there was a breath in there for someone to not be asked something over and over, and actually have their answer not only heard - but comprehended, our media system wouldn't become a joke.

[update: 5:41pm Eastern] LGF confirms a point made on the Drudge Report that Kerry's campaign has stated that the Senator's first Purple Heart may have been self-inflicted.

Posted by Tom at August 24, 2004 3:10 PM | TrackBack | IM This

Comments

I have to disagree with some of your comments. Malkin was not "sandbagged", she put her foot in her own mouth when she said "said some veterans question Kerry getting the Purple Heart for self-inflicted wounds."

The interview was going fine until she said that. Matthews then tried to get her to say answer who was saying that and she kept stammering and finally said, it's in the book. He then asked her several times if she believed that the wounds were self-inflicted. Finally after getting flustered, she said yes.

Matthews "hammered her" as you call it, because she throws out this comment with no regards to whether it was true or not, and then she refused to answer why she was saying that. I applaude Matthews for making her explain herself, rather than just let her get out her Republican party standard line.

Even if the wound was self-inflicted, per the rules regarding Purple Hearts, Kerry would have been still entitled to receive it, if it happened in combat, and it was not due to gross misconduct on his part.

Posted by: Joe D at August 24, 2004 3:00 PM

Joe - by "sandbagged" I wasn't talking about Matthews hammering her in the Q&A, I was talking about the consistency in which talk shows "switch up" their shows and guests in a way that leaves some guests at a loss or talking about topics they weren't ready to talk about. They prepare just as much as a host prepares (or doesn't, in some cases). The point here is that Malkin did indeed say that this is what she read in the book - it's not that Kerry doesn't deserve the Purple Heart because, as you stated, it's in combat.

Irrelevant of the "truth" of something, when she answered that this was what the people who wrote the book said. She wasn't giving her opinion over whether he "shot himself," she was pointing out that the Swift Vets were stating that the injury had nothing to do with enemy fire.

Posted by: Tom at August 24, 2004 3:52 PM